You Are Not Your Student's Savior


The Teacher Savior Complex
I love my students. Anyone who knows me knows that I could talk about my students for hours. I will talk so fast and so enthusiastically that I cough on my own spit... I know, not the prettiest picture but you get the idea! I get excited about their accomplishments, I worry about them, and I'm invested in who they're becoming as people.
But there's something I think we need to be careful of as educators, particularly those of us who really love what we do. And that's what I've come to refer to as the teacher savior complex.
I think a lot of us secretly want to be that teacher. You know, the one a student talks about twenty years later when they're asked who had the greatest influence on their life. We've all seen the inspirational teacher movies, and admittedly, I'm a sucker for them. When Joshua Henry thanked his voice teacher in his acceptance speech at the Tony Awards, I was a puddle of tears.
But I've been thinking a lot about the difference between wanting to have a positive influence on a student's life and wanting to be an important person in their life versus being the only source of truth of them. I also think it's worth examining our motivations occasionally.
Am I asking, "How can I serve this student?" or am I asking, "How can this student become part of my legacy?"
Who Gets the Credit?
I'm probably one of the biggest cheerleaders of my students. I love sharing their college acceptances, their competition results, the roles they've booked, and all the other exciting things happening in their lives. I'm proud of the work we've done together, and I don't think there's anything wrong with that. But I didn't audition for that college. I didn't stand in front of those adjudicators. I didn't spend hours in a practice room preparing for that performance.
My student did all that work. I was a small portion of it.
I think we sometimes become so accustomed to using student accomplishments as a means of establishing our credibility as voice teachers that we forget how many factors contributed to those accomplishments. There were likely other teachers, school music programs, theatre directors, supportive family members, and a whole host of experiences that contributed to that student's development long before they walked into our studio. And, of course, there was the student themselves!
We Cannot Manufacture Intrinsic Motivation
One of the hardest things for me to come to terms with as an educator is that I can't want something more than my students do. It never ends well.
Sometimes I'll have a student with an extraordinary amount of natural ability, and my brain immediately starts going through all the things they could potentially do. There are competitions they could enter, summer programs they could attend, roles they could audition for, and colleges where I think they would thrive. Meanwhile, that student might just really enjoy singing.
I think this is especially important to consider when working with children and adolescents. They're still figuring out what they enjoy and what they want to do with their lives. Our enthusiasm for their abilities shouldn't become another source of pressure for them.
There are also times when a student has established a goal for themselves but isn't particularly motivated to do the work necessary to accomplish it. I can help them develop practice strategies, provide resources, and have some very candid conversations with them about their expectations. But at some point, they have to take responsibility for their own learning.
I can certainly create conditions that encourage intrinsic motivation, but I can't manufacture it for them.
Think About Your Own Education
When I think about where my knowledge as an educator comes from, it's really all over the place. So much of my teaching philosophy comes from my undergraduate degree in education and my experience working in early childhood education. Other aspects came from my graduate work in curriculum and instruction. I've done various vocal pedagogy training programs, attended conferences, read books and research articles, and had countless conversations with other voice teachers. I've learned from directors, from performing, from watching other people teach, and even from things I've stumbled across on social media.
And I cannot begin to quantify how much I've learned from my own students. Sometimes they'll ask me a question that sends me down a rabbit hole of research because I've never actually thought about something from their perspective before.
So, given the number of people who have contributed to my education, why would I ever expect my students to get everything they need from me?
There are voice teachers who know considerably more than I do about certain genres. There are teachers who have spent years studying specific areas of vocal pedagogy that I've only begun to explore. There are also teachers who might explain something differently than I do, and for whatever reason, that explanation just makes more sense to a particular student.
I want my students to benefit from those educators.
Your Student Wants to Study With Someone Else? Wonderful!
I think an interesting exercise in self-reflection is to consider how we feel when one of our students expresses an interest in studying with another teacher. Does it make us uncomfortable? And if it does, why?
I would love for my students to attend workshops, take masterclasses, participate in summer intensives, and study with people who have different areas of expertise than I do. I'd also love for them to come back and tell me what they learned. Sometimes another voice teacher will explain something I've been working on with a student for months, and suddenly the student gets it. Obviously, there's a small part of me wondering why my seventeen explanations didn't work, but I'm thrilled that the eighteenth one did! I'm also probably going to ask the student how that teacher explained it because I'd like to know.
The whole point was for my student to understand the concept. Why should it matter to me who finally got them there?
Our Students Don't Owe Us Loyalty
This is a tougher one. When you've worked with a student for several years, particularly a child you've watched grow up, there is an emotional component to that relationship. It's difficult sometimes when students leave, and I don't think we have to pretend otherwise.
But I also don't think students should feel guilty about exploring other educational opportunities because of their relationship with us. Sometimes a student needs something that I'm not particularly well equipped to provide. Sometimes their interests have changed. And sometimes another teacher might just be a better fit for them. That's a possibility we have to be willing to entertain, too.
I would hate for a student to continue studying with me out of a sense of obligation when there's another educational opportunity they're genuinely interested in pursuing. Similarly, I don't think our students owe us public acknowledgment for every accomplishment or a career in the arts because we've invested years in their training. Those years of education have value regardless of what they ultimately decide to do.
In fact, one of the things I hope I'm doing through my teaching is helping students become informed consumers of their own education. I want them to be able to identify what they need, ask questions, and advocate for themselves. At some point, that might involve a decision that I wouldn't have made for them.
Helping Isn't the Same as Rescuing
I think people who are drawn to teaching are often people who really like to help. I'm certainly one of those people, and sometimes I have to remind myself that constantly solving problems for someone isn't necessarily the most helpful thing I can do.
Even within a voice lesson, I have to be conscious of this. If I'm giving a student the same correction every single week, at what point do I need to stop and spend some time teaching them how to recognize that issue independently? What happens when they're in a practice room and I'm not there?
The same applies to artistic interpretation. I might have a very specific idea of how I would perform a piece, but my student might have a completely different interpretation of it. Assuming their choice is supported by an understanding of the material, why do I need them to make the same choice I would?
There are also times when students are struggling with things that extend well beyond the scope of a voice lesson. I care about those things because I care about the student, but that doesn't mean I'm qualified to address all of them. Sometimes serving a student means helping them find someone who is.
We're Not Here to Make Disciples of Ourselves
There's a passage in 1 Corinthians 3 that I often think about in relation to education.
Paul is addressing the divisions among people who have begun identifying themselves with particular spiritual leaders. Some are claiming to follow Paul, while others are claiming to follow Apollos. Paul responds by explaining that he planted, Apollos watered, but God gave the growth.
I love that illustration so much. Obviously, the context of the passage is quite different from voice teaching, but I think about how applicable it is to the way we sometimes view our role in a student's education.
I might be the teacher who establishes a student's technical foundation. Another teacher might be the person who introduces them to jazz. Another might be the person who helps them discover who they are as an artist. And who knows how many other people will contribute to their development over the course of their lifetime?
I also think about that passage when it comes to our individual teaching philosophies. I don't want disciples of my teaching methodology. I don't want students going into other educational settings feeling the need to defend everything I've ever taught them.
I would much rather have a student who comes back from college and says, "Hey, my professor said something that was really different from what you taught me. Can we talk about it?"
I would thoroughly enjoy that conversation.
We Have to Keep Learning, Too
I worry that when we become overly invested in being the expert in someone's life, it becomes increasingly difficult to admit when we're wrong or when we don't know something.
There are things that I taught ten years ago that I would approach very differently today. I'm sure there are things I'm teaching today that I'll approach differently ten years from now. Sometimes I read something that makes me reconsider a technique I've been using. Sometimes I attend a training and realize there's an entire area of vocal pedagogy that I haven't spent nearly enough time studying. And sometimes it takes working with a particular student to realize the limitations of my own approach.
I think we should be comfortable letting our students see that process. We're asking them to spend their time with us doing something they're not necessarily good at yet. We're asking them to receive criticism, reconsider habits, and be willing to experiment with unfamiliar things.
Are we still doing those things ourselves?
How Can I Serve You?
I've found myself coming back to this question quite a bit in recent years:
How can I serve this particular student?
For one student, that might mean challenging them considerably more than I have been. For another, it might mean taking some of the pressure off. It might mean introducing them to repertoire they wouldn't have thought to explore or having a difficult conversation about their practice habits. It might even mean recommending another teacher.
I don't think approaching education from a place of service means that we relinquish our professional judgment. I have fairly strong opinions about curriculum and what constitutes a comprehensive voice education, and I'm not particularly shy about sharing them with my students. But I also have to recognize that each student has their own reasons for pursuing an education in the arts. Their reasons may be very different from mine.
When I think about my students twenty years from now, I don't necessarily care whether they're still singing the repertoire I assigned them or using the terminology I taught them. Some of them might not even be singing anymore. But I do hope that they're curious people. I hope they know how to seek out information, recognize when they need help, and make informed decisions. I hope they feel comfortable questioning things they've been taught, including things they've been taught by me.
And if they're fortunate enough to encounter other educators who have a tremendous influence on their lives, I hope they'll tell me about them. I'd probably like to learn from those educators, too. I can love my students and be invested in their lives without needing to be the central figure in their success. I think that's something worth reminding myself of periodically.
I am their teacher, not their savior.




Comments