Building Community and Connection Instead of Competition


Our Students Are Watching Us: Cultivating Community Among Voice Teachers
One of my favorite moments at a NATS Student Auditions event had absolutely nothing to do with singing:
After the finals concert, I was watching a group of students from different studios exchanging Instagram handles, laughing, and making plans to stay in touch. Some of these students had just competed against one another, and I loved that they were so excited to have made new friends. Without an event like this, they might never have met!
It got me thinking about the relationships we cultivate as voice teachers and how those relationships might influence the way our students interact with one another. Through my involvement with the National Association of Teachers of Singing (NATS), I've spent quite a bit of time reflecting on what we're modeling for our students, particularly when it comes to competition and community.
The Loneliness of Private Teaching
Private voice teaching can be a surprisingly isolating profession. We spend a significant portion of our working hours in a room with one other person. We develop our own teaching philosophies, establish our own studio cultures, and invest a tremendous amount of time in the development of our students.
Depending on our teaching circumstances, we may not have many opportunities to observe other educators. We don't necessarily have colleagues down the hallway to consult when we're struggling with something, and professional development is often something we have to seek out independently.
I also think the independent nature of our work can make us particularly susceptible to comparison.
When another teacher's student wins an award, books a role, or receives an exciting college acceptance, it's natural to wonder what that teacher is doing in their studio. We invest so much of ourselves in our work that it can be difficult not to internalize our students' accomplishments and disappointments as reflections of our own abilities. I think there's actually a lot of value in wondering what another teacher is doing differently, provided we're approaching that question with genuine curiosity.
Learning From Other Teachers
One of the things I've appreciated most about my involvement in NATS (for those that don't know, NATS is the National Association of Teachers of Singing) is the opportunity to become familiar with the work of other voice teachers. I've encountered teachers whose students demonstrate remarkable technical consistency, teachers who have a real gift for working with young voices, and teachers whose approaches to musical interpretation have made me reconsider some of my own teaching practices.
I'm genuinely interested in what other teachers are doing in their studios. What exercises are they using? How do they explain certain technical concepts? What repertoire are they assigning? How are they approaching challenges that I've also encountered with my students?
I think one of the exciting things about vocal pedagogy is that there is always something else to learn. Even when we have a fairly established teaching philosophy, we're going to encounter students whose needs require us to revisit some of our approaches.
I've benefited tremendously from becoming more familiar with the strengths of my colleagues. Sometimes another teacher has an explanation for something I've struggled to communicate effectively for years. Sometimes they introduce me to repertoire I never would have considered assigning. I would miss out on so much professional growth if I allowed myself to be intimidated by the strengths of other educators or if I chose to see them as rivals instead of colleagues.
Competition and Rivalry
I'm a big advocate for the educational benefits of competition. Preparing for a NATS audition gives students a tangible goal to work toward, an opportunity to perform under pressure, and access to feedback from other professionals. There's also tremendous value in learning how to navigate disappointment, particularly for students who are considering careers in the performing arts. However, I think we need to be mindful of the way we talk about competition in front of our students.
If students regularly hear their teachers questioning another singer's success, criticizing another teacher's work, or expressing frustration when a student from another studio wins, I wonder how that shapes their perception of their peers.
The performing arts are already competitive enough. I would hate for my students to miss out on meaningful friendships or potential collaborative relationships because they've been conditioned to see other singers primarily as competition.
I want my students to be ambitious. I want them to work hard, prepare thoroughly, and feel proud of what they've accomplished. I also want them to be able to recognize and appreciate a beautiful performance by another singer, even if that singer ends up receiving the award they were hoping to win. We can teach both!!
We're Not Supposed to Be Their Only Teachers
Teachers are not saviors.
When we become particularly invested in being the person responsible for a student's success, it can be difficult to embrace the influence of other educators. But our students don't belong to us and they can learn from so many people in their artistic journey!
Throughout their artistic lives, they're going to encounter voice teachers, directors, conductors, coaches, and colleagues who will influence their development in ways that we haven't. Some of those educators will have strengths in areas where we have considerably less experience. I want my students to benefit from that and not see that as a threat to my ego.
I also don't want a student to ever feel uncomfortable bringing something into a lesson that they learned from another educator. Ideally, we can have a conversation about it, explore it together, and consider how it might fit into the work we're already doing. If I'm encouraging lifelong learning in my students, it seems only reasonable that I should demonstrate that same willingness to learn from others in my own professional life.
NATS Is More Than an Audition
As Student Auditions Co-Director for NATS Boston, I spend a lot of time thinking about what we want students to take away from our events.
There are obviously a tremendous number of logistical considerations involved in organizing auditions, but I'm also interested in the educational experience students are having throughout the day. Maybe a student receives a comment from an adjudicator that helps something we've been working on in lessons finally make sense. Maybe they hear another singer perform a piece of repertoire that they immediately want to learn. Perhaps they discover that they're a little more comfortable performing under pressure than they thought they would be. Sometimes they find another person who is equally obsessed with an obscure musical that none of their friends at school have heard of, and then the world feels a little less small for that student.
There is also something really valuable about having a day when so many voice teachers are in one place. For those of us who spend much of our week teaching independently, it's an opportunity to catch up with colleagues, talk about repertoire, exchange ideas, and see some of the wonderful work happening in other studios. I would love for us to continue thinking about how we can cultivate those opportunities for both students and teachers.
Some of the Teachers Who Have Made Me Better
It feels appropriate to include some very specific examples of the educators I've learned from. Much of my teaching philosophy has been informed by conversations with colleagues, observing their students, participating in professional development, and simply paying attention to the things other educators do particularly well.
These are ten educators whose work has influenced my own, and links to their personal studios when relevant!
I've always admired Beth's technical teaching. Her ability to develop singers who are equally capable of navigating classical, commercial, and musical theatre repertoire is particularly exciting to me given my own interest in cross-genre training. I've learned a great deal simply from observing the versatility of her students.
One of the things I appreciate most about Eva is her kindness and patience as an educator. She has a wonderful ability to meet students where they are. I particularly admire her work with young singers across genres, as well as the work she does with students at Dean College. She's a great example of how important it is to understand the individual student we're working with.
I'm fortunate to have Teresa as my department head at Walnut Hill. In addition to being an exceptional technical voice teacher, she is a fierce advocate for her students and their well-being. I have so much respect for the way she prioritizes the needs of the whole student alongside their development as a singer.
I particularly admire Kim's work with adult learners. There is something really beautiful about creating a space where an adult who sings purely for enjoyment receives the same care and respect as someone pursuing a professional career. Her nurturing approach and the way she makes students feel comfortable asking questions are things I really value as an educator.
Something I love about Katie is that, despite her exceptional training and expertise, she approaches teaching with such humility and joy. There is a genuine enthusiasm for her students and their learning that I find incredibly refreshing. I really admire how consistently she puts her students first.
Stephanie Lento
Stephanie's work with neurodivergent students is something I appreciate and value so, so much. As someone who is also passionate about this area of education, I value the way she recognizes and accommodates individual learning needs without making assumptions about what a student is capable of accomplishing artistically.
Julia Toomey
I've learned a lot from Julia's emphasis on breath as a foundation for singing. I appreciate the attention she gives to developing those foundational skills and how that work contributes to the confidence and musicianship of her students.
Sandy's breadth of knowledge is remarkable. She brings decades of experience in jazz, opera, and musical theatre, and her knowledge of repertoire across those genres is extraordinary. I've particularly appreciated her expertise in developing healthy, sustainable voices in jazz. Given my interest in cross-genre vocal training, there is so much about her work that I admire.
Shannon is kind, passionate, and collaborative. Her enthusiasm for the craft just oozes out of her and makes her an asset to every student that she encounters. She's also an insanely gifted performer, and her students have the opportunity to learn from her both from watching her on stage and during lessons.
Nicole Soriano
Nicole is a musical theatre teacher at Walnut Hill School for the Arts, and while she is not a voice teacher, I had to give her a shoutout! One of my favorite things I've learned from her is the use of intention verbs. This has become a significant part of the work I do with students preparing for college musical theatre auditions. It's been a major asset in getting students to make more specific dramatic choices within their songs. I also wanted to include Nicole because I think there's enormous value in learning from educators outside of our specific discipline. Some of the most useful tools I've adapted into my voice teaching have come from teachers who aren't voice teachers at all.
I could easily continue this list. There are so many educators whose work has informed my own, sometimes in ways they probably aren't even aware of. I also think we could all benefit from being a little more vocal about the things we admire in one another.
Our Students Are Watching Us
I keep coming back to those students exchanging Instagram handles at NATS auditions. I hope they continue to support one another, attend each other's performances, and maintain some of those friendships as they pursue their own artistic endeavors. I hope every voice teacher Is modeling those same kinds of relationships for them.
Our students hear the way we talk about other teachers. They notice how we respond when another studio's student wins an award, and they see whether we're willing to celebrate accomplishments that we had nothing to do with. Particularly with younger students, I think we sometimes underestimate how much those interactions inform their understanding of what it means to be a part of an artistic community.
Of course, I want my students to become wonderful singers. But I also hope they'll become the kind of people that other artists enjoy working with. I hope they'll be generous with their knowledge, interested in what their colleagues have to offer, and genuinely supportive when good things happen to their colleagues and peers.
The world is mean enough, let's not make voice teachers another iteration of Mean Girls.




Comments